Remote jobs diminish hiring bias against mothers
By Julie Greco
The “motherhood penalty” – a workplace bias that assumes mothers are less committed to their careers, resulting in fewer opportunities, lower pay and slower advancement – could be reduced by shifting jobs from in-person to remote, according to new research by Claire Daviss, assistant professor of organizational behavior at the ILR School.
“We found that when we asked respondents who they would prefer to hire, giving them the options of a mom and a childless woman, if it was a remote job, they didn’t have a preference,” Daviss said. “However, if we labeled it as an in-person job, they preferred a childless woman to a mom.”
The research, “Remote Work and the Motherhood Penalty,” was published Nov. 12 in the journal Contexts. Co-authors are Emma Williams-Baron and Erin Macke, both Ph.D. students at Stanford University.
“There has been some research that shows that motherhood penalties are smaller when the job involves a flexible work arrangement,” Daviss said. “But we did think there was a chance that we would have seen the opposite of our results and that moms would actually be penalized more for remote work because many people are skeptical of remote workers’ commitment to work.”
For the study, the researchers asked 1,500 participants to read a job description that was randomly assigned as either in-person, remote or hybrid. Then participants reviewed the resumes of two job applicants with distinct yet similarly prestigious prior work and educational backgrounds. The key difference: one applicant was a parent (as indicated by a resume line noting that they volunteered with their child’s Parent-Teacher Association and by interviewer notes that the applicant mentioned their children) and the other was not. Participants were asked which applicant they thought the company would hire and which applicant they would personally prefer to hire.
When asked which applicant they thought the company would hire, the motherhood penalty was clear. For both in-person and remote jobs, participants predicted that the company would prefer the childless woman more than 60% of the time and the mother less than 40% of the time.
However, when asked which applicant they would personally prefer to hire, the participants’ answers depended on the job. For the in-person position, nearly 60% of participants preferred to hire the childless woman (58.3%), while just over 40% preferred the mother (41.7%), a gap of about 17 percentage points – similar to their predictions of the company’s preferences. For the remote job, on the other hand, there were no significant differences in their probabilities of choosing the childless woman or the mother.
“It was statistically equivalent to a coin toss,” Daviss said. “That suggests we may be able to reduce the motherhood penalty with more remote jobs, which is very exciting, because it’s been hard to reduce it in most jobs and occupations. It’s been an enduring problem, so having any amount of traction on it is a big deal.”
The researchers also indicated that the question of who the company would hire is likely an indicator of current social norms, because the answers reflect what participants believe others believe. Their findings point to the persistent social norm of a motherhood penalty, but also imply that norms may be shifting, since individuals personally preferred childless women only when evaluating applicants for in-person jobs.
“That cultural shift matters, because remote work is here to stay,” Daviss said. “It exploded in the COVID 19 pandemic, and it has persisted in many companies. There are many questions about what that might mean for the future of labor market inequality. This gives us an answer to one piece of that picture. It suggests we might expect to see less inequality among mothers and non-mothers, at the very least.”
Furthermore, the motherhood penalty greatly contributes to the gender wage gap, she said.
“So, to the extent that we care about the gender wage gap – which I think a lot of people do – our research is pointing to one way that we might be able to reduce that kind of inequality.”
Julie Greco is communications director at the ILR School.
Media Contact
Adam Allington
Get Cornell news delivered right to your inbox.
Subscribe