An eastern bluebird feeding insects to one of its chicks.

Temperature variability reduces nesting success

Cold snaps and heat waves associated with climate change lead to more deadly nest failures for songbirds, new Cornell research has found.

Songbirds are already nesting earlier in spring because of warmer temperatures, but greater exposure to temperature variability is another danger that is especially perilous for nestlings, according to the study, “Inconsistent Shifts in Warming and Temperature Variability are Linked to Reduced Avian Fitness,” published Nov. 16 in Nature Communications.

“When we talk about temperature changes, the focus is mostly on averages,” said co-lead author Conor Taff of the College of Agriculture and Life Sciences, a researcher in the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology. “But all creatures, including humans, interact with weather conditions right in the moment, not with long-term averages. Even a one or two-day period when it’s really cold or really hot can be incredibly challenging even if the average temperature hasn’t changed. Changing temperature averages and temperature variability are two different components of climate change.”

To understand how temperature variability might affect nesting success, the researchers analyzed 300,000 breeding bird records submitted to the Cornell Lab of Ornithology’s NestWatch project between 1995 and 2020. They pinpointed the coldest three-day day period and the hottest three-day period for each one of the nests and then looked at whether those values predicted lower nesting success. Success was measured by how many nestlings survived to fledge.

“We found that 16 of the 24 species we studied had reduced reproductive success when a cold snap occurred during the incubation or nestling stages,” Taff said. “Eleven of 24 had reduced success when a heat wave occurred during the breeding season. Aerial insectivores were the most sensitive to temperature extremes, especially cold.”
The vast majority of birds feed insects to their young, regardless of their final diet, and cold snaps reduce insect availability. If these episodes occur when nestlings are most vulnerable, they can trigger a mass die-off. During a cold snap, adult birds may move away to find survivable conditions, which leaves eggs and nestlings exposed to cold and lack of food.

“It’s the nestlings that really get hit hard because they can't regulate their own body temperature yet,” said co-author Ryan Shipley, Ph.D. ’18. “Nestlings also grow at an exponential rate during the first week or two of life and if insect activity drops because of a cold snap, the young birds likely won’t survive.”

Taff and Shipley also examined 100 years of weather data to see if there have been changes in the timing of cold snaps and heat waves during the March through August breeding season in the United States and Canada. Although they found no clear pattern in the timing of temperature extremes, they do note that it's getting warmer everywhere.

“Even if nestlings somehow manage to survive a cold snap or heat wave, there may still be long-term consequences affecting the overall health of the birds,” Shipley said. “We’re only looking at a brief snapshot during early life and cannot measure long-term health in an unbanded wild population.”

Previous tree swallow studies by these authors have shown that temperature during development is important because it’s directly linked to the rate of nestling growth and their body mass when they fledge. That, in turn, influences how likely they are to survive, make it through migration and return to breed the following year. Therefore, changes in the variability and timing of temperature extremes and shifts in the breeding season can combine to bring about life-changing consequences for individuals and for bird populations. 

Pat Leonard is a writer for the Cornell Lab of Ornithology.

Media Contact

Jeff Tyson